Compare
A cash-out refinance can turn high-interest card and loan payments into one payment, and because mortgage rates typically run well below credit card and personal loan rates, what goes out each month can drop meaningfully. Put part or all of that monthly difference toward principal and you can pay the whole thing down faster too. Using the payment savings, you can pay your principal down exponentially and pay less interest over time.
| Topic | Cash-out refinance | 2nd mortgage | HELOC | Home equity investment (HEI) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The big advantage | High-interest payments become one payment, and what goes out each month can drop meaningfully. Put part or all of the difference toward principal and you pay less interest over time. | Keeps your first mortgage in place. | The full amount up front. Put back what you don't need now and only pay on what you're using. Choose fixed or variable rates. | Typically no monthly payment. |
| Credit scores | Options for credit scores over 500, depending on the program. | Typically needs a higher credit score. | Typically needs a higher credit score. | Options for credit scores over 500, depending on the program. |
| How you get the money | A new, larger first mortgage. The extra comes as cash at closing and pays off your debts. | A one-time lump sum from a second loan on top of your existing mortgage. | The full line amount up front at closing. Put back what you don't need right now, and you only pay on what you're using. When the draw period ends, the balance you owe is set on a repayment schedule. | A lump sum from an investor in exchange for a share of your home's future value. |
| What happens to your first mortgage | Replaced by the new loan, so you're left with one mortgage and one payment. | Stays as it is. The 2nd mortgage sits behind it. | Stays as it is. The HELOC sits behind it. | Stays as it is. The investor's interest is recorded against the home. |
| Monthly payment | One payment, often at a fixed rate. | A second payment, usually at a fixed rate. | A second payment, at a fixed or variable rate you choose. | Typically none. You settle up when you sell, refinance, or reach the end of the agreement. |
| Cost picture | Closing costs similar to a first mortgage, with one rate on everything you owe. | Usually lighter closing costs than a full refinance. | Usually lighter closing costs, and some lenders charge an annual fee. | Upfront fees, plus the investor's share of your home's value at settlement, which grows if the home appreciates. |
| Documentation usually needed | A full mortgage application, plus an appraisal or, on some loans, an automated valuation (AVM). | Income (sometimes verified electronically), credit, and an appraisal or AVM. | Income (sometimes verified electronically), credit, and an appraisal or AVM. | Often more flexible on credit and income, plus an appraisal. |
| Best fit | Larger balances, solid equity, and a first mortgage you're ready to restructure. Strongest when the monthly savings go toward principal. | A first mortgage worth keeping and a set amount to pay off. | Put back what you don't need so you only pay on what you're using. | Homeowners who need cash but can't take on another monthly payment. |
Program availability, guidelines, and pricing vary by lender and by the state where the property is located, and change without notice. This comparison is educational, not a credit decision or an offer, and it is not tax or legal advice. Program restrictions apply.
Here's what most people don't know. A lower monthly payment is the part everyone notices, and a lot of people stop there. The bigger move is what you do with the difference.
Say your cards and loans used to take a big bite out of every month, and the new mortgage payment takes a smaller one. Keep sending part or all of that difference to the mortgage as extra principal. Every extra dollar comes straight off the balance, so the loan can pay off sooner and you pay less total interest than you would making only the regular payment. You get breathing room in the budget now, and the old debt doesn't have to stretch out over the full life of the loan.
That's why I walk every client through paying the difference toward principal: the debt is now secured by your home, and making only the regular payment over a long period can cost more in total than paying the cards off sooner would have. With a plan for the difference, you get the relief now and a faster payoff later. I'll map both versions out with your real numbers so you can see it before you decide.
I'm a broker, so I can put all four of these side by side with your real numbers instead of pushing the one product a single lender happens to sell.
For many homeowners paying off debt, the cash-out refinance comes out on top: one payment, monthly savings, and a faster payoff when you put the difference toward principal. When your first mortgage is worth keeping, a 2nd mortgage or HELOC can do the job without touching it. And if another monthly payment just won't fit, a home equity investment is worth a look.
I'll show you what each one does to your monthly payment, and how fast the balance comes down if you put the savings toward principal, before you decide anything.
It can be, especially with larger balances. Several high-interest payments become one mortgage payment, and your monthly outgoing can drop meaningfully. The homeowners who get the most out of it put part of that monthly difference toward principal, which shortens the payoff.
Put the monthly savings to work. Sending part or all of the difference toward principal shortens the payoff and can cut the total interest you pay compared with making only the regular payment. I show you both versions side by side before you decide.
Typically yes, and an extra principal payment comes straight off the balance. Some loans have prepayment terms, so I confirm that up front before you count on it.
Typically when your current first mortgage has terms worth keeping. A 2nd mortgage or HELOC lets you reach your equity without replacing it. A 2nd mortgage gives you a lump sum with a steady payment, while a HELOC gives you the full amount up front and lets you put back what you don't need so you only pay on what you're using, with your choice of a fixed or variable rate.
An HEI gives you a lump sum today in exchange for a share of your home's future value. There's typically no monthly payment. You settle up when you sell, refinance, or reach the end of the agreement, and if your home appreciates, the investor's share grows with it. It can make sense when another monthly payment won't fit, but I always compare it with a loan first.
